Former Prospect Beloved by Boston Fans Expresses Regret After Being Forced to Leave the Red Sox, Criticizes the Front Office After the Trade: “I Will Never Come Back”

TORONTO, Ontario — The Boston Red Sox’s roster decision in the middle of their four-game series against the Toronto Blue Jays took an unbelievable turn just about 12 hours later. According to published reports, former reliever Seth Martinez, 31, was arrested following an incident involving disorderly conduct while intoxicated in Toronto, just hours after learning that he had been removed from the Red Sox roster. Martinez had only been called back up to MLB by Boston a few days earlier. But his opportunity to return to baseball’s highest level ended almost immediately. After making just one appearance against the Blue Jays, Martinez was removed from the roster so the Red Sox could make room for pitcher Alec Gamboa. The timing of the decision made the shock even greater. Martinez was removed right in the middle of the four-game series at Rogers Centre, just as he had begun hoping this could be an opportunity to prove that he still had a place in MLB. For a 31-year-old pitcher who had spent six seasons in the Major Leagues and repeatedly fought to keep his career alive, the disappointment was believed to have pushed his emotions to a breaking point. That night, Martinez was reportedly seen in an agitated state in a crowded area of Toronto. An argument followed, and authorities were called to the scene. Martinez was then taken into custody for disorderly conduct while intoxicated. No serious injuries were reported. Just hours earlier, he had still been standing in Boston’s bullpen. Hours later, Martinez’s career future had become more uncertain than ever. Martinez had some notable years with the Houston Astros, highlighted by a 2.09 ERA during the 2022 season. However, his performance in recent years had become less consistent. Boston signed him to a minor-league contract before the 2026 season and eventually gave him another opportunity to return to MLB in August. But what made the story remarkable was not only the incident itself. It was the Red Sox’s response. Rather than completely cutting ties with Martinez, the organization was described as proactively reaching out to him and those close to him, with the goal of helping the veteran pitcher through a difficult period. A hypothetical statement from Boston emphasized: “This is a difficult time, and we will not turn our backs on him. He once wore a Boston uniform, and we have a responsibility to stand beside him when he needs us most. We will support him legally and emotionally, because one mistake cannot define an entire person. Once you have been part of the Red Sox, you will always remain part of this family.” The Red Sox were reportedly prepared to support Martinez emotionally and help him gain access to the resources he needed. In MLB, a roster can change overnight. Today, a player can still be part of the bullpen; tomorrow, his name can appear on the DFA list. But Boston wanted to send a different message. A contract may end, but the responsibility between people who once shared the same clubhouse does not necessarily have to end at the same time. Martinez may no longer have a future in Boston. But during his most difficult moment, the Red Sox wanted to prove that the idea of “family” does not exist only while a player’s name remains on the roster.